8 Common UI Design Mistakes Hurting Your Conversion Rate

Your website’s design directly impacts how many visitors turn into customers. Bad UI can frustrate users, drive them away, and hurt your revenue. Here are the 8 most common UI design mistakes and how to fix them:

• Overcrowded Interfaces: Cluttered layouts confuse users. Simplify with whitespace, grids, and clear grouping.

• Weak Mobile Design: Over 4 billion people use mobile internet. Ensure your site is responsive, with large touch targets and readable text.

• Slow Page Speed: 47% of users expect pages to load in 2 seconds or less. Compress images, optimize code, and use CDNs.

• Poorly Designed CTAs: Buttons should stand out with contrasting colors, clear text, and strategic placement.

• Missing Visual Structure: Lack of hierarchy makes navigation harder. Use size, spacing, and alignment to guide users.

• Brand Inconsistencies: Mismatched fonts, colors, or visuals reduce trust. Stick to a design system and consistent guidelines.

• Hard-to-Use Forms: Long or confusing forms lead to abandonment. Simplify fields, add clear labels, and improve validation.

• Poor Accessibility: Accessibility errors like low contrast or missing alt text exclude users. Follow WCAG guidelines to make your site usable for everyone.

Quick Fixes for Better Conversions:

By addressing these issues, you’ll create a smoother user experience and significantly boost your conversion rates.

5 Website Redesign MISTAKES Killing Your Conversions

1. Overcrowded Interfaces

A cluttered interface can overwhelm visitors, often driving them away. In fact, 38% of users leave a website if its layout or content feels too crowded. This can hurt your conversion rates as users struggle to navigate and find what they need.

Too many elements on a page can exhaust users' mental energy, leading to frustration and abandonment.

Clean Layout Principles

A well-organized, clean layout helps reduce clutter and makes navigation easier:

• Use whitespace effectively: Leave enough space between elements to separate content blocks clearly.

• Adopt grid systems: Align elements consistently for a more organized look.

• Group related items: Keep similar content together to maintain clear sections.

"Good design is actually a lot harder to notice than poor design, in part because good designs fit our needs so well that the design is invisible." - Don Norman, The Design of Everyday Things

Setting Visual Priority

A strong visual hierarchy ensures that users focus on the most important elements.

Text Hierarchy Guidelines

Once the layout is decluttered, guide user attention by:

• Enlarging essential elements.

• Using contrasting colors to highlight key areas.

• Breaking content into manageable sections.

• Ensuring navigation is consistent throughout.

Simplifying doesn't mean cutting out functionality - it’s about organizing content better. For example, IMDb's actor pages often struggle with competing elements, excessive ads, and crowded sidebars, making it hard for users to focus on the main content.

2. Weak Mobile Design

Poor mobile design can seriously hurt your conversions. With 4.66 billion people actively using mobile internet, making your site mobile-friendly isn't just a good idea - it's a must.

Mobile Design Basics

Great mobile design starts with interfaces that work smoothly on all devices. Here are a few essentials:

Other key elements include:

• Visual Hierarchy: Use short paragraphs and progressive disclosure to make content easy to scan.

• Navigation: Stick to familiar patterns and limit choices to avoid overwhelming users.

• Performance: Speed things up by optimizing images and using lazy loading.

"Create a layout that fits the screen of a device. Users should see primary content without zooming or scrolling horizontally." - Apple Developer

Why Start with Mobile Design?

A mobile-first design approach begins with the limitations of smaller screens and then scales up for larger devices. This strategy boosts conversions by:

• Focusing on What Matters Most: Highlight the key information to keep users engaged.

• Simplifying User Flows: Cut down on friction by reducing data entry, using device features like cameras for quick input, and adding tools like auto-complete.

• Improving Feedback: Use visual, audio, or haptic cues to confirm actions, so users feel confident about their interactions.

Taking mobile design seriously isn't just about keeping up - it's about staying ahead.

3. Page Speed Issues

Slow-loading pages can seriously hurt your conversions. With 47% of customers expecting a page to load in 2 seconds or less, speed is critical. Studies show that pages loading in 2.4 seconds have a 1.9% conversion rate, while those taking 5.7 seconds or more drop to just 0.6%. Fast load times are just as important as clear design when it comes to keeping users engaged.

Image and Media Speed Tips

Images are often the main culprits when it comes to slow pages. Here are some ways to speed things up without losing quality:

Walmart saw a 2% boost in conversions for every 1-second improvement in load time, and COOK achieved a 7% increase with a 0.85-second improvement. Small changes can make a big difference.

Technical Speed Fixes

Beyond images, technical tweaks can further enhance your site’s speed:

1. Server Performance: Upgrade to VPS or dedicated hosting to reduce server response times.

2. Content Delivery: Use a CDN to serve content from servers closer to your users.

3. Code Optimization: Minify and combine CSS and JavaScript files to cut down on HTTP requests.

"Technology makes what was once impossible possible. The design makes it real." – Michael Gagliano

Mobify found that improving homepage load time by just 100ms led to a 1.11% increase in conversions. On mobile, the stakes are even higher - every second of delay can slash conversions by as much as 20%.

To maintain peak performance, keep monitoring and tweaking. Some additional tips:

• Enable Gzip compression to shrink file sizes.

• Use browser caching to speed up load times for returning visitors.

• Optimize database queries for quicker data retrieval.

• Load non-essential scripts asynchronously.

One e-commerce site used a combination of image compression, caching, and database optimization to speed up load times by 30%, resulting in a 15% jump in conversions. These adjustments show that even small improvements can lead to big wins.

4. Poorly Designed CTAs

Badly designed call-to-action (CTA) buttons can seriously hurt conversions. In fact, 53% of Fortune 500 companies fail to follow basic CTA design principles on their homepages, and 70% of small businesses don’t include CTAs on theirs at all. These numbers highlight just how important it is to get CTA design right.

Making CTAs Stand Out

To grab attention, your CTAs need to be visually appealing. Here’s what helps:

Real-world examples show the impact of thoughtful design. ADT improved button placement and styling, leading to a 62% increase in conversions. Susty-Party went even further, boosting conversions by 250% simply by making their buttons easier to find. Clearly, the way your CTAs look and where they’re positioned can make all the difference.

Writing Better CTA Text

The words on your CTA are just as important as the design. A small change in phrasing can have a big impact. For instance, ContentVerve increased click-through rates by 90% by switching their text from "Start your free 30-day trial" to "Start my free 30-day trial". That subtle shift to first-person language made the CTA feel more personal.

Here’s how to craft better CTA copy:

• Use clear, action-oriented verbs.

• Add time-sensitive language to create urgency.

• Highlight specific benefits to the user.

• Keep it short and to the point.

Firstleaf nails this approach with their CTA: "Send me the best 3-pack." It combines personal language with a focus on value, making it more persuasive.

Sometimes, less is more. Scanitto found that removing extra "Buy Now" buttons actually increased their sales. Testing different CTA styles and placements can also yield surprising results - Brafton reported an 83% jump in blog post revenue after strategically placing CTAs.

Well-designed and carefully worded CTAs are essential for driving conversions, proving that even small tweaks can lead to big wins.

5. Missing Visual Structure

When visuals lack organization, users have to work harder to navigate, which can hurt conversions. If users can't quickly locate what they need, they'll often leave. A cluttered interface creates mental strain, making clear visual cues essential for guiding users through content.

Thomas Lowry, Figma Advocacy Director, explains it well:
"Think of a user as someone asking you directions. If you just showed them a map and expected them to memorize it, they'll probably get lost. But if you point them to a sign that says their destination is this way, they can follow the signs from there … That's a much better experience. UI design principles help you set up signs users can follow towards their goals - one click, scroll, or interaction at a time."

This perspective highlights the importance of building a clear and intuitive layout.

Building Clear Structure

A well-structured layout helps users move effortlessly through your design, creating a better experience. Clear hierarchies are key to guiding users. Here's how effective websites organize their content:

Take Hipcamp.com, for example. Their homepage uses bold typography and strategic font sizes to emphasize the phrase "Find yourself outside", instantly conveying the site's purpose. Similarly, Spotify's iPhone app uses thoughtful spacing to create clear sections, reducing confusion by grouping related elements.

To refine your visual structure, try these approaches:

• Establish Clear Hierarchy
  Prioritize content by importance. Use size, color, and contrast to direct attention. For instance, Jersey Dairy Milk employs scaled typography to highlight key product details, like the type of milk and fat content, making it easy for users to spot.

• Group Related Elements
  Use ample whitespace to separate unrelated items and maintain consistent styling to build trust. As AllieMarie Design explains, "Hierarchy is about visually ranking different elements in a design. In short, it determines what the viewer sees first."

"A consistent-looking design goes a long way in establishing trust with your visitors and in creating an enjoyable experience. Plus, it will help your users learn their way around your app much faster."

Well-organized designs make it easier for users to find what they need and take action. Always validate your design with user testing - what seems logical to you might not be intuitive for others.

6. Brand Design Inconsistencies

When your brand elements don’t align, it can confuse users and damage their trust in your site. This lack of consistency forces visitors to relearn how to navigate your platform, leading to frustration and lower conversion rates. Studies show that visual elements like images (40%) and color (39%) play a big role in website design. Without consistency, the impact of your earlier design efforts is weakened.

"Design is in the details - fonts, colors, visuals, and more. Inconsistencies erode credibility and undermine marketing efforts."

Consistency isn’t just about aesthetics - it’s about creating a seamless experience that builds trust and reinforces your brand identity.

How to Keep Brand Elements Consistent

Focusing on a few key areas can help maintain a uniform brand design:

Here’s how you can make sure your brand stays consistent:

• Create Clear Guidelines
  

  Document everything: color codes, typography, spacing rules, and visual styles. This ensures everyone follows the same playbook.

• Use a Design System
  

  Build reusable UI components and maintain consistent patterns across your site. Regular design audits can help catch inconsistencies early.

• Monitor and Update
  

  Keep an eye out for outdated elements. Review all interface touchpoints and update older components to align with current standards.

Regular usability testing is crucial. It helps identify outdated designs - whether in error messages, form fields, or secondary pages - that could disrupt the user experience. A little attention to detail goes a long way in maintaining a polished and trustworthy brand.

7. Hard-to-Use Forms

Forms are often the last step between users and conversions, but many websites make them unnecessarily complex. Studies show that conversion rates drop by about 10% when forms have more than six fields, compared to forms with just three fields. This drop highlights how important form design is to your user interface strategy. Below is a table showing common form issues that can frustrate users.

"When your form provides less friction and it's easier to fill out, users are more likely to complete them." – Sam Stemler, Web Ascender

Making Forms User-Friendly

To design better forms:

• Ask for only essential information. Group related fields together and use a clear visual hierarchy to make the form easy to follow.

• Use clear labels above input fields. Ensure fields are appropriately sized for the expected content length.

• Improve validation by:

  • Explaining formatting requirements clearly.

  • Using proper input types (e.g., email, phone number).

  • Validating fields in real time.

  • Displaying specific correction instructions when errors occur.

• Enhance accessibility. Ensure proper keyboard tab order and use visible labels instead of relying solely on placeholder text.

• Set smart defaults. Use autocomplete for common inputs and avoid pre-selecting dropdown options. For fewer than five choices, opt for radio buttons to improve usability.

8. Poor Accessibility

Accessible design isn't just about inclusivity; it's also about improving user experience and reaching a wider audience. Studies reveal that 96.7% of accessibility errors fall into six primary categories, with low-contrast text impacting over 80% of websites.

Here’s a breakdown of common accessibility issues and how they affect conversions:

"Why would you want to make something that some people can't use?" - Cathryn Rowe, Interaction Designer

Basics of Accessibility

The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) outline clear standards to ensure websites are usable for all. For example, normal text should have a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1, while large text requires a ratio of 3:1. These standards help make your site functional for everyone.

Take HubSpot as an example: after adding descriptive headings to client sites, they saw engagement rise by 23%, bounce rates drop by 15%, and conversions increase by 8%. Addressing accessibility issues can lead to similar improvements for your site.

Here are three key actions to get started:

• Improve color contrast

  • Use tools like WebAIM’s Color Contrast Checker to ensure text and elements meet contrast requirements.

  • Avoid hard-to-read combinations like light gray text on white backgrounds.

• Add alt text for images

  • Write clear, descriptive text for every image.

  • Include details about the purpose of interactive elements.

• Structure content with headings and labels

  • Use a logical heading hierarchy (H1 to H6) to organize content.

  • Label all form fields visibly and ensure keyboard navigation flows smoothly.

For example, Carbon Health used the AXE Chrome Extension to audit their homepage and found 28 accessibility violations. By addressing these issues systematically, they resolved all errors within days.

Accessibility features don’t just help individuals with disabilities - they enhance usability for everyone. Features like clear visual hierarchies, proper text contrast, and structured content improve the overall experience, which naturally leads to higher conversion rates. By prioritizing accessibility, you’re also making your website more effective at turning visitors into customers.

Conclusion: Creating High-Converting UI Designs

Building on the design challenges we've covered, let’s look at how to craft a UI that drives conversions. A well-designed UI can directly influence conversion rates. For example, studies show that simplifying choices can dramatically boost conversions - when a retailer reduced jam options from 24 to 6, purchase rates jumped from 3% to 30%.

Key Points to Keep in Mind

A user-first mindset is crucial. With attention spans averaging just eight seconds, every design element needs to serve a purpose. Interfaces should guide users naturally toward conversion points while staying consistent with the brand and accessible to all users.

"Conversion rate mistakes can silently sabotage your success, turning potential customers away before they even know what you offer."

These principles summarize the key insights from our discussion on UI design pitfalls and solutions.

Related posts

• 10 Signs Your Website Needs a UX Overhaul

• 7 UI/UX Design Trends Shaping Digital Products in 2025